Every cowboy worth his salt knows a cutting saddle is more than just horse tack. It can be a game-changer for your performance.

This article cuts through the clutter to spotlight the top players in the cutting saddle game. We're talking about heavy-hitters like Teskey's, Billy Cook, and Circle Y, plus rising stars like Cactus, Jeff Smith, and McCall.

Whether you're eyeing a brand-new saddle or scouting for a top-notch used one, we've lined up the best options for you.

Best Selling Western Horse Cutting Saddles

HR Hud Roberts Signature Series Cutting Saddle
This is a high quality saddle that is a perfect choice for those who prioritize quality. This series features saddles crafted from Herman Oak Leather with an oiled fiberglass-covered tree. The saddle offers a 6 3/4" gullet and a 13 1/2" bar spread. It's designed with pointed skirts and hand-tooled floral patterns, coupled with a smooth finish. The saddle also includes 2" wood bell stirrups. Known for exceptional leather quality, craftsmanship, and comfort, the HR Hud Roberts Cutting Saddle from the Signature Series is designed for long, demanding rides.
Jeff Smith Cutter Saddle
Get your hands on this 17 Inch Used Jeff Smith Cutting Saddle, now available with free shipping. Jeff Smith is known for saddles that fit your style, and this one is no exception. it has a wide tree size made of fiberglass-covered wood, a 17-inch roughout seat, a 4.75-inch cantle height, and a 12.5-inch swell width. The horn measures 3x2 inches, and it has in-skirt rigging, feather concho hardware, a 28.5-inch skirt length, and weighs approximately 43 lbs.
Cactus Saddlery Cowhorse Saddle
This Cactus cutting saddle is perfect for show pen activities like reining, cutting, or working cowhorse. It has a low cantle and tall gullet to keep rider and horse centered during dynamic movements. Robust enough for roping and dallying, it's a go-to choice for top horse show champions. This saddle boasts a wood, fiberglass-covered tree with a lifetime warranty, Quarter Horse bars, an 8” x 6 1/2" gullet, a 3 1/2” cantle height, and weighs around 40 lbs. It includes in-skirt rigging, a 6” flank cinch, premium Hermann Oak leather, stainless steel hardware, genuine wool skin lining, all handcrafted in Greenville, Texas.
Circle Y Cutting Saddle
This older 16" Circle Y brown cutting saddle is in great shape for its age, well-maintained with a smooth jockey, fenders, and tooled back and seat. The tree is tight, the fleece fine, and it's marked as handmade by Circle Y. It's got a newly replaced glove leather seat, measuring about 16 1/4", and feels like a snug 16". Comes with durable leather rear off billets, aluminum stirrups, and a 7" gullet with Full Quarter Horse bars.
Billy Cook Flat Seat Pro Cutter
This Billy Cook cutting saddle is a showstopper, perfect for competitions, yet tough enough for regular cutting work. Its lightweight build, combined with a pro cutter tree, gives you a bigger range of motion than other saddles. It has a Cutter-style leather covered horn and oxbow stirrups, it's ready for action. The striking two-toned appearance is from half-breed basket-stamped russet leather contrasted with the rough side out seat and fenders. Billy Cook has crafted this cutting saddle to meet, if not exceed, your expectations.
Teskey's Ranch Cutting Saddle
Teskey's Ranch Cutting saddle gets the nod for its top-notch leather, comfy seat, and slick look. But, there's a hitch – some riders have griped about the metal bits used for tweaking stirrup length, saying they've roughed up the fenders. But, it's still a solid value for the money. This saddle is cut out for both training and regular riding. It has a 16" seat, a 28" long skirt, a smooth seat and fenders, and the rest in roughout. Plus, it's has slotted conchos and strings, so it's all set to go and in fine shape.

Best Selling Brands: Western Horse Cutting Saddles

Cutting saddles can be great quality or made of poor materials that fall apart. We put together a list of great Cutting saddles, like Teskey's, Billy Cook, and Circle Y.

HR Hud Roberts Saddlery
When quality is non-negotiable, HR Hud Roberts cutting saddles, from the Signature Series, deliver. They're all about top-grade leather, craftsmanship, and comfort for those long rides.
Jeff Smith Custom Saddles
If you want a saddle that's tailored to your style, Jeff Smith's custom-fit options are your go-to.
Cactus Saddlery
Gaining ground for their solid build, Cactus saddles are on the upswing.
Circle Y Saddlery
Circle Y is where style meets substance. These saddles have a following for a reason and are up for grabs in various stores and online.
Billy Cook Saddles
Combining time-honored craftsmanship with modern flair, Billy Cook saddles are a nod to enduring quality.
Teskey's Saddlery
Known for rugged durability and comfort, Teskey's saddles are a top pick for pros.

In a nutshell, this lineup represents the best of the best in cutting saddles. Whether it's a brand-new purchase or a savvy second-hand deal, these options are sure to enhance your performance in the arena.

Where To Buy Used Cutting Saddles

Looking for a cutting saddle without breaking the bank? Used saddles are the way to go, and there's no shortage of places to find them.

When buying used, always ask about the saddle's history, check for wear and damage, and if possible, try it out to ensure it's a good fit for you and your horse. With a bit of patience and research, you can snag a great deal on a used cutting saddle.

Teskey's Cutting Saddles

Teskey's Cutting saddles are where practicality meets quality, and they're a go-to for riders serious about their gear.

Bottomline: Teskey's cutting saddles are a smart buy. They're about quality and longevity, with a range of options to suit your riding style. Whether you're a seasoned pro or just getting into cutting, a Teskey's saddle is a solid investment in your riding future.

Billy Cook Cutting Saddles

Billy Cook cutting saddles are a solid choice for anyone who values both tradition and quality. Here's some straight talk about what makes Billy Cook saddles stand out:

Bottomline: If you're in the market for a cutting saddle that combines traditional craftsmanship, quality materials, and features that actually cater to real riding needs, Billy Cook is a brand worth considering. These saddles are not just about heritage; they're about delivering performance and value that both new and experienced riders can appreciate.

Circle Y Cutting Saddles

Circle Y saddles are a big deal in the equestrian scene, and for good reason.

Bottomline: Circle Y saddles are where tradition meets innovation. They've got a saddle for pretty much every western riding style, focusing on comfort and performance. If you're serious about your riding and willing to invest in top-notch gear, Circle Y's got your back.

Cactus Cutting Saddles

Cactus saddles are a big player in Western riding and rodeo circles, earning props for their toughness, comfort, and solid performance.

Bottomline: Cactus saddles are a solid choice, especially if you’re into barrel racing. They deliver on quality and comfort, making them a hit with pros and enthusiasts alike. Just weigh the pros and cons against what you need in a saddle, and you’re good to go.

Jeff Smith Cutting Saddle

Jeff Smith saddles are a big deal in the cutting world, known for top-notch quality and craftsmanship.

Bottomline: Jeff Smith saddles are about quality, durability, and attention to detail. They're a hefty investment, but for those in the cutting discipline, especially professionals, they're a popular and sensible choice.

HR Hud Roberts Cutting Saddle

HR Hud Roberts cutting saddles, from the Signature Series, are all about quality, comfort, and versatility. They're made for those long days in the saddle, built to last with top-tier materials.

In short, HR Hud Roberts cutting saddles are a solid choice for those who value quality, functionality, and style in their riding gear.

What Is A Cutting Saddle?

Cutting saddles are a specific style of Western saddle designed for cattle work, especially in the cutting arena where a rider separates a cow from its herd.

Their design focuses on maintaining rider balance while not hindering the horse's agility and movement. These saddles usually feature a low cantle and a high pommel with a slender, tall horn. The seat is generally flat but slightly raised near the pommel.

Cutting saddles are perfect for team penning, sorting, and various cutting events.

What Is A Cutting Saddle Used For?

Designed for the sport of cutting, where riders isolate a cow from its herd, cutting saddles are all about maintaining rider balance and enabling the horse's agility.

These saddles come with a long, flat seat, a low cantle, and a slight rise near the pommel. They also feature a tall, thin horn and high, wide swells to help the rider effectively anticipate and manage the cow's movements.

While not intended for roping, cutting saddles are well-suited for other activities like team penning, sorting, and various cutting competitions.

What Makes A Good Cutting Saddle?

A quality cutting saddle incorporates specific design elements to meet the demands of cutting activities. These include taller pommels, swells, and forks, coupled with taller and thinner horns.

The cutting saddle features a flatter seat that rises more towards the pommel, often with a "rough" texture on the seats and fenders to enhance grip. The cantles are lower, aiding in quick, agile movements.

The cutting saddle is equipped with reinforced rigging for added durability. These design choices focus on providing support and balance to the rider while facilitating quick stops, sharp turns, and overall agility during cutting events.

The flatter, unpadded seat design also allows for better contact and feel with the horse, crucial for effective communication and control.

Cutting Saddle vs Reining Saddle

Cutting and reining saddles have significant differences.

Reining saddles have lower horns and swells (max 3 1/2" for the horn, 8" for the swells) to allow free movement of the rein hand.

Cutting saddles, on the other hand, are built for the intense action of cutting - quick stops, sharp turns, and overall agility. They have higher pommels, swells, and forks, a taller, thinner horn, a flatter seat that rises near the pommel, rough-textured seats and fenders for grip, lower cantles, and strong rigging.

Cutting Saddle vs Roping Saddle

Cutting saddles are made for quick moves in cutting events. They have long, flat seats, low backs (cantles), and high fronts (pommels). They use a type of leather called roughout where your legs touch, helping with grip. The horns are tall and thin, and the seats rise a bit near the front for easier movement and better feel of the horse.

Roping saddles, on the other hand, are built strong for roping. They have tough frames (trees), solid horn for roping, and suede seats designed for balance. The front of these saddles (pommels) is always high, giving good support, and the back (cantle) height can vary.

In short, cutting saddles are all about quick, agile moves and staying close to the horse, while roping saddles are made to be tough and keep the rider stable when roping animals.

Can You Rope In A Cutter Saddle?

Yes, you can use a cutting saddle for roping, but there are a few things to think about.

Cutting saddles are made for quick moves and good communication with the horse in cutting events. They're not as heavy-duty as roping saddles but work fine for light roping, like catching cattle in a field or treating them.

The thing is, cutting saddles have a different tree (the frame of the saddle) and seat design from roping saddles. This difference might make it trickier to rope consistently. A cutting saddle’s flat seat and other unique features could affect how comfortable you are and how well you can do certain roping tasks.

So, while roping in a cutting saddle is doable, keep in mind it's different from using a roping saddle and consider what you need for your roping work.

Cutting Saddle vs Ranch Cutter Saddle

The difference between a cutting saddle and a ranch cutter saddle is all about their design and use.

A cutting saddle is made for agility and quick movements needed in cutting events. It has a long, flat seat, low back part (cantle), a slight rise near the front (pommel), a tall, thin horn, and wide fronts (swells). It's not really meant for roping but can handle light tasks like catching animals in a field.

The ranch cutter saddle, on the other hand, is versatile for various ranch tasks like trail riding or arena work. It's built with a strong horn for roping and a narrow seat for comfort during long days. It's heavier and more durable, with a taller, thicker horn than a cutting saddle, making it better for roping activities.

So, while both are comfortable and durable, the ranch cutter is more all-around, especially for roping, whereas the cutting saddle is specialized for cutting events.

Richard Sutherland

RichardSutherland@bitsnspurs.org

Richard is a western lifestyle author for Bits N' Spurs, the weekly newsletter that keeps pace with today's rodeo. His articles are featured on dozens of rodeo and Western related websites and provide a window to the world of cowboy culture.

Female
mid-level
male